• About
  • Bowdu the Shiba Inu
    • Bowdu’s health journal
  • Bowpi the Basenji
    • Bowpi’s health journal
  • Index of Dog Movies
    • List of Dog Movie Lists
  • On the same page
  • Reviews
  • Contact

The House of Two Bows 雙寶之屋

~ a basenji, a shiba, and their human companions

The House of Two Bows 雙寶之屋

Daily Archives: 3 March 2011

Hachiko’s droopy ear

03 Thursday Mar 2011

Posted by M.C. in Digging in the Libraries, Observations & opinions

≈ 7 Comments

Tags

akita, ears, hachiko, korean dogs, nationalism, Nihon Ken Hozonkai, nippo, pricked ears, saito hirokichi, 忠犬ハチ公

I got to thinking about ears and pricked ears after reading one of Aaron Skabelund’s fascinating articles, “Fascism’s Furry Friends: Dogs, National Identity, and Purity of Blood in 1930s Japan” in The Culture of Japanese Fascism, edited by Alan Tansman (Durham: Duke University Press, 2009, 155-182).

Saito Hirokichi, founder of the Nihon Ken Hozonkai (Society for the Preservation of the Japanese Dog, aka Nippo), had a lot at stake in laying the foundations for the future of the Japanese breeds. While he wasn’t fabricating the standard entirely from scratch, there were a few characteristics that he was adamant about inscribing into modern foundations. In a 1937 radio address aired by Nippon Hōsō Kyōkai (NHK), Saito laid out both physical and temperamental characteristics that his preservation society sought to fix in Japanese breeds. “The various traits of the Japanese nation — difficulty in getting used to anyone outside its master’s family, being intelligent but not adept in expressing emotions compared to Western dogs, diffidence and stubbornness, and extreme courage — have been ingrained into the personality of Japanese dogs” (Saito in Skabelund, 164), he broadcast to his listeners, unabashedly generalizing essential notions of his country to a temperament he preferred to see manifest in its dogs. Also, “All ‘Japanese’ canines […] had to have ‘small, triangular ears that stand erect’ and a ‘large and powerful curled tail'” (171). How else, for example, could you differentiate a native Japanese breed from the similar-looking Jindo or Pungsan dogs on the Korean peninsula?

Hachiko on the inside page of a 1934 storybook (photo from Wikipedia)

Where then does this place poor Hachiko, or rather, “Loyal Dog Hachiko” (Chūken Hachikō 忠犬ハチ公) as he is popularly known in Japan? The entire lore of his unflagging fidelity to his dead master has become a permanent fixture to his name, like the bark of a tree that grows around a nail driven into its trunk. As eager as Saito and others were to enfold Hachiko’s touching story into the standard of Nihon ken, they also had to defend his breed “purity” given that his physical characteristics fell short of what the preservation society aimed to standardize. They insisted that his physical imperfections — his drooping left ear and his slumped tail — were a result of long-term disease, and not from questionable bloodlines adulterated by foreign dogs.

Hachiko, Silent Guardian
Photo by madd0g11. Hachiko statue at Shibuya station.

I’m not interested in whether or not Saito was correct in his assessment of Hachiko’s genetic purity. What I think is more interesting is the fact that these cosmetic details have been insistently covered up, aestheticized, and “corrected,” time and time again. While the final rendition of Hachiko in bronze statuary, sculpted by Andō Shō, retains the detail of the drooping left ear (much to the chagrin of Saito and crew, who had no time to commission a more idealized model before the statue was cast), the taxidermied body of Hachiko now on display at the National Science Museum of Japan was stuffed with both ears erect, and tail elegantly curled.

Hachiko, taxidermied and displayed at the National Science Museum of Japan (photo from Wikipedia)

And this is to say nothing of Hachiko’s appearance in recent filmic adaptations, where his coat color isn’t even white anymore, but rather, the signature red of a Japanese Akita!

What is lost in these anatomical interpretations?

To me, the drooping ear is an emblem of the years of hardship that Hachiko suffered on the streets. He did not turn his back on any happy home to keep the flame alive for his dead master. The fact is that there was no other home for him to go to. All parties involved were more interested in maintaining the myth of the downtrodden wanderer who had nothing else other than the memory of his master; his impoverishment only heightened the tragic poignancy of the story, and that’s why it had to be maintained. The pedagogical value of Hachiko’s story did not have to be steered towards imperialistically-tinged notions of unerring devotion towards a singular, grand master. It could have been a lesson in humane charity, in animal welfare, in collective social responsibilities towards homeless pets, or really, any needy living creature. But the fact that any alternative interpretations were drowned out by the dominant ideology of loyalty and national unity in a time of heightened militarism is represented by that single, falsely pricked ear.

At the end of this all, I’m not denying that Hachiko’s story is truly moving, and taps into some universal desire to express and anthropomorphise the human-canine bond. But every time I read or see another version of the story, I can’t help but be reminded about how it is fiction, and just how particularly the “facts” have been plotted, amplified, muted, reconfigured, and calibrated to achieve very pointed emotional effects. And these fictions are never mere fiction; they are powerful, compelling, and enduring. Yet, even the inauthentic details that comprise these fictions can be given historical specificity. The story has been told a certain way for some reason(s), and that is just as interesting to me as the story itself.

Skabelund’s article goes into much greater detail on how “The nationalization of an everyday animal, purported to possess an ancient and intimate relationship with native place and people, served to bolster and to emotionalize allegiance to the nation-state” (157), and how it is not entirely spurious to link Japanese dog breed enthusiasts’ efforts at establishing a “pure, indigenous cultural [canine] aesthetic” (158) with roughly contemporaneous German efforts to do the same. Lest you be immediately turned off by Skabelund’s labeling of both practices as Fascist in spirit, let me assure you that he is fully aware of the difficulties in slotting any prescribed definitions of Fascist practice onto another country with its own historical developments. The angle of his analysis comes out of the demands of the anthology, which are explained in greater detail for anyone who wants to read it for themselves. And I highly recommend doing so.


ETA: Hachiko was in the news just recently, as University of Tokyo researchers announced the reason for his cause of death. “They say Hachiko died of cancer and worms, not because he swallowed a chicken skewer that ruptured his stomach – as legend had had it.” The chicken skewer theory was actually loudly contested at the time of its emergence, particularly by Saito who could not accept such an ignoble death and insisted that disease was what eventually felled the great Hachiko. So he was right all along, and though he’d only seen Hachiko once, he was able to spot his decrepit condition, yet did nothing to help prevent or alleviate the diseases festering within. So it was still an ignoble death, after all. Would Hachiko have been infested with worms if he had been in a clean, safe home? Who knows…

Edit 10 February 2012: Columnist Robb Fritz retold the Hachiko story rather succinctly for McSweeney’s in a column entitled, “Wait for Me.”

Follow us on Facebook

Follow us on Facebook

My say (recent posts)

  • Bowdu 寶肚, the Precious Tummy 25 August 2020
  • Bowpi 寶媲, the Precious Companion 2 August 2020
  • Roll of 28, Day 28: Yesterday’s clouds were dramatic — today is ok 1 March 2015
  • Roll of 28, Day 27: She wore red shoes 27 February 2015
  • Roll of 28, Day 26: First dibs 26 February 2015
  • Roll of 28, Day 25: My first fish taco 25 February 2015
  • Roll of 28, Day 24: MGMT 24 February 2015
  • Roll of 28, Day 23: Illuminated perspective 23 February 2015
  • Roll of 28, Day 22: Desirous duo 22 February 2015
  • Roll of 28, Day 21: The View from the DJ corner 21 February 2015

Your say

Down the Rabbit Hole… on Top 5 Dogs in Tim Burton movie…
Leslie on Bowdu 寶肚, the Precious Tu…
M.C. on Bowdu 寶肚, the Precious Tu…
NY Earthling on Bowdu 寶肚, the Precious Tu…
M.C. on Bowdu 寶肚, the Precious Tu…

Day by day

March 2011
M T W T F S S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031  
« Feb   Apr »

Where we’ve been

What we talk about when we talk about dogs

  • Bowdu the shiba inu (432)
  • Bowpi the basenji (427)
  • Digging in the Libraries (49)
  • Film (81)
  • Finances (54)
  • Food, drugs & other ingestibles (120)
  • Health (79)
  • Human escapades (91)
  • Links (69)
  • Observations & opinions (38)
  • Polls (1)
  • Reviews (31)
  • Sightings (183)
  • Signs of the Beast Bay (17)
  • Sound and music (19)
  • Stuff you can buy (29)
  • Taiwan reminiscences (43)
  • Trinkets, toys, and memorabilia (13)
  • Videos (29)

★ Basenji Peeps

  • 2 becomes 1
  • Basenji blogs on Blog Mura
  • Basenji Forums
  • Basenji Shaun
  • Basenji Troublemakers
  • Basenji University
  • BRAT – Basenji Rescue and Transport
  • BRAT Blog
  • Crazy Basenji
  • Curly-tailed Brigade
  • Follow the Piper
  • Hero, Yosal, Iivari & Aapo
  • Johnny Pez
  • Junk Thief
  • Performance Puppy
  • Sneak a Peek
  • Super Eggplant
  • Super Senjis
  • Suzuki and strawberries you are Basenji
  • Whiskered Paintings

★ Shiba Links

  • 3 Shiba Super Heroes
  • A Winnie Day
  • Adventures of Conker
  • Adventures of Olli
  • Demon Dog
  • Dog Newbie
  • Eat Play Love
  • F'Yeah Shiba Inu
  • From the House of the Fox Dogs
  • Hibiki Tree
  • Hinoki the Shiba
  • I Am Shiba
  • I'm Ichigo
  • I.Am.Kaiju
  • Jenna and Snickers
  • Jonathan Fleming
  • Kenzo the Shiba
  • Kyota the Shiba
  • Life as an Art Form
  • Life With Kai
  • Loki the Shiba
  • Mac the Shiba Inu
  • Maggie the Mini Shiba
  • Maru in Michigan
  • Masakado Shiba Inu
  • Misadventures of a Shiba Inu
  • Misanthropic Shiba
  • Mulder – My life as a dog
  • My Shiba is a Diva
  • Obey Zim!
  • Oh Henley!
  • Our Shibal Inu
  • Saya's Adventure
  • Shiba Inu blogs on Blog Mura
  • Shiba Inu Forum
  • Shiba Inu Hawaii
  • Shiba Shake
  • Shio the Shiba
  • Sophelia's Adventures in Japan
  • Taro the Shiba
  • Volunteers 4 Paws (formerly Inu Baka)
  • Yuki the Shiba Inu

Rescue

  • Americas Basenji Rescue
  • Animals Taiwan
  • BACS Dog Volunteer Blog
  • Basenji Club of SE Wisconsin
  • BRAT – Basenji Rescue and Transport
  • Camp Basenji Rescue
  • Colorado Basenji Rescue
  • MASR – Mid Atlantic Shiba Rescue
  • Medfly Basenji Rescue of Southern California
  • MSIR – Midwest Shiba Inu Rescue
  • Muttville
  • National Shiba Inu Rescue
  • Northern California Shiba Inu Rescue
  • Northern Nevada Shiba Rescue
  • Northwest Shibas4Life
  • NYC Shiba Rescue
  • Safe Harbor
  • Saving Shibas, Inc.
  • Shiba Inu Rescue of Florida
  • Shiba Inu Rescue of Texas
  • Shiba Scout Rescue
  • SIRA – Shiba Inu Rescue Association
  • Tri-State Shiba Inu Rescue
  • TUAPA – Taichung Universal Animal Protection Association
  • Walkin' the Bark

We're not just Shibasenji-centric (it's just what we're used to)

  • Animal Emotions
  • Animals Being Dicks
  • Anything for a Cookie
  • Ask Dr. Yin
  • Bark Blog
  • Brad Anderson
  • Canine Corner
  • Cats and Squirrels
  • Cats on Film
  • Companion Animal Psychology Blog
  • Countersurfer
  • Cute Overload
  • Daily Coyote
  • Desert Wind Hounds
  • Do You Believe in Dog?
  • Dobermann Daze
  • Doctor Barkman Speaks
  • Dog Art Today
  • Dog Food Advisor
  • Dog Milk
  • Dog Snobs
  • Dog Spies
  • Dog Star Daily
  • Dog's Best Friend
  • Doggerel
  • Dogs Make Everything Better
  • Dogs of San Francisco
  • Dogster: For the Love of Dog
  • Forumosa Pet Forum
  • Gardens for Goldens
  • Girl with the Gae
  • Happy Bark Days
  • Hound from Africa
  • Hound in Hanoi
  • KC Dog Blog
  • Life By Pets
  • Modern Mechanix – Animals
  • Mongrels of the World
  • Musings of a Biologist and Dog Lover
  • My Imperfect Dog
  • My Rotten Dogs
  • Nihon Ken
  • Other End of the Leash
  • Pedigree Dogs Exposed
  • Pet Museum
  • Poodle (and Dog) Blog
  • Prick-Eared
  • Querencia
  • Raised By Wolves
  • Rubicon Days
  • Ruffly Speaking
  • Science of Dogs
  • Shutterhounds
  • Sniffing the Past
  • Tinkerwolf
  • Ulatulat
  • VIN News
  • We Live in a Flat
  • Wolf Dog Blog
  • YesBiscuit!

african dogs aggression akita allergies art basenji basenji mixes basenji rescue and transport breeders budgeting canine body language canine dental canine hypothyroidism canine play chinese dogs collies comfortis cone of pride and triumph cone of shame corgis dehydrated dog food dog food dog movies dog parks dog play dog songs dog toys dog treats drugs finances foot licking formosan mountain dog german shepherds giveaways grooming hair loss health tests hemopet honest kitchen jack russell terrier japanese art japanese dogs japanese film labrador retrievers meetups off leash orthopedic foundation for animals pet finances pet store a pit bulls primal raw puppies quirks raw diet raw fish raw turkey rescue roll of 28 shiba inu shiba mixes sighthounds skin care sleep soloxine sponsored reviews stray dogs supplements taipei taiwan taiwan dogs terriers thyroids training tugou vet

Freshly sniffed (featured links, regularly rotated)

SPARCS 2014 topics

Fox colors

Why are some breeds of dogs more popular than others?

Owner Profile: The Rare Breed Braggart

10 great books on dogs

Bureau of Labor Statistics: Spending on Pets

Links to articles on village dogs

Badges

DogTime Blog Network Badge Dog Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory Photobucket

Pets Blogs
Pets
Dog Topsite

We've greeted...

  • 542,996 guests

Honors

Online Colleges Top Blogs

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 171 other followers

Get in touch

scroll up to drop us a line via the comment form!

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Follow Following
    • The House of Two Bows 雙寶之屋
    • Join 171 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • The House of Two Bows 雙寶之屋
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar